Speaking before the top one hundred women
business and political leaders of the Republic of South Africa,
Opposition leader Benazir Bhutto compared Pakistan's fight for
democracy to South Africa's Fight against Apartheid.
Bhutto, who flew into Johannesburg yesterday
received wide coverage in the South African print and electronic
press.
She received a warm welcome from the
professional women at the Women's Conference to commemorate Women's
Week in South Africa. The title of the Conference was Women and
Leadership: Against the Odds. She was the key note speaker.
Extracts of the Speech follow:
It is a particular honor for me to be with you
this morning at this gathering of women as part of your Nation's
historic celebration of Women's Day.
What makes this more special is that we meet in
South Africa. All during the time I was growing up in Pakistan, and
going to school in America and England, the words "South
Africa" were a metaphor for injustice, and terror and inhumanity.
And then, miraculously, the words "South
Africa" were transformed into a metaphor for people all over the
world who are oppressed. South Africa became a metaphor for hope, for
the triumph of justice, and a demonstration that determination and
courage can create miracles.
Ladies and gentlemen, if apartheid can crumble
in South Africa, racism, sexism and bigotry can crumble in every
corner of this planet.
I stand here with you truly in the epicenter of
world freedom. Yet the world still is complex; a world that defies
simple explanations and simple solutions; a world that is still very
much in transition from one set of political realities to another.
The world is less the simple place than we had
dreamed it would be in the late eighties, with communism
disintegrating and democracy taking root all over Eastern Europe,
Southeast and Southwest Asia, and Africa.
In those days, the World talked about how to
spend the anticipated on domestic needs and international
responsibilities. And in Pakistan, we were finally coming to grips
with restoring democracy and economic reform after a decade of bitter,
brutal Martial law.
But, the forces of dictatorship did not
relinquish their iron grip of my country so easily. Today, I travel to
South Africa to speak with you at a difficult time for me, and my
country. And in light of your bitter history of political repression,
I would hope that you would open your hearts to the suffering of my
people.
This is a time of crisis and tragedy in
Pakistan.
History has sadly come full circle on the
subcontinent.
A military regime once again rules my homeland
with an iron fist. The last vestiges of democratic institutions are
being assaulted and dismantled.
No Parliament. No state assemblies. No
independent judiciary. No human rights. No free press. No independent
labor organizations. Heavily controlled and regulated NGOs.
Women are being thrown back into another era,
into another century of repression and exploitation.
We witness a tragic rise in exploitation of
religion for political purposes.
A stalemate between India and Pakistan in
Kashmir.
An unsuccessful summit between the two
nuclear-armed nations of South Asia only last month collapsing in
shambles.
It is not a pretty picture. It is a dangerous
picture.
This is Pakistan in the year 2001.
The disintegration of democracy in Pakistan did
not come overnight, and it did not come in one military coup. Since my
government was overthrown four years back Pakistan has drifted
rudderless in a sea of conflict and violence -- an agenda of vengeance
and a hijacking of democracy.
The heirs to the dictator General Zia ul Haq who
terrorized Pakistan with an iron fist for a decade, were resurrected
with new names and new methods.
My successor elected in a military backed
fraudulent election imposed a one party dictatorship on Pakistan.
I was the first victim. And then my party. And
then the constituencies across the breadth of my country that
supported the agenda of democratic and economic reform.
And then the Prime Minister attempted to topple
the one institution that brought him to power and that could defend
itself.
His attempt to topple the Army failed. But now
we all pay the price.
The military stepped in to restore order and
democracy in our Nation. It succeeded in neither. And the last
pretenses of democracy and democratic institutions have evaporated.
To tighten their grip on political opposition,
the President of our country was toppled. The power of the courts was
usurped. Judges were sacked. Journalists were assaulted. Censorship
was imposed. The rights of women were thrown back a generation.
Ladies and gentlemen,
Just as in South Africa during the terror of
apartheid, supporters of democracy and human rights were forced into
exile once again.
I know it has become the fashion both in the
developed and developing world over the last decade, to destroy
leaders' reputations by innuendo, allegation and rumour. This strategy
now even has a name -- the politics of personal destruction.
This is true not just in Pakistan, but even in
the most developed democracies.
But the scale to which this was orchestrated in
Pakistan against my party defied anything seen in the world. It was a
relentless, devastating and overt assault on justice in an attempt to
eliminate my leadership and to destroy me personally.
Bureaucrats, businessmen and cabinet members
were arrested and tortured to perjure themselves to fabricate false
charges. I was truly blessed that they remained strong and would not
be tortured and threatened into betraying me. But their failure to
coerce witnesses didn't stop my successors from proceeding.
I was pressured and humiliated in increasingly
desperate attempts to force me to quit politics.
My own husband was accused of even more
ridiculous and scurrilous charges, including, the unspeakable slanders
of murdering my own brother and trafficking in drugs. And his father
was arrested to pressure him.
My husband and father-in-law are still behind
bars, hostages to my political career.
The full extent of the plot against me was
revealed through the extraordinary release of bugged conversations,
proving beyond doubt that the charges against me were contrived.
I used to think, naively, that an election alone
could change things for the better. Now I realize that a country needs
more than democratic elections, it needs the rule of law.
An election can bring in a new Parliament and a
new government.
It cannot, however, bring in a new bureaucracy
or intelligence system.
It cannot, without an independent judiciary,
lift the veil on the Machiavellian intrigues that take place that are
both brutal and barbaric and undermine civil society.
It cannot give acknowledgment, without fair
hearing, to the victims of tyranny -- those who lost their lives, then
livelihoods, their families, their peace of mind, who were tortured,
imprisoned or forced to flee to foreign lands for refusing to commit
perjury and destroy the path of justice.
Does it sound familiar, ladies and gentlemen?
South Africa of the seventies. Pakistan today.
The suffering is not of one person, not of one
family, not of one political party, but of an entire nation.
Ladies and gentlemen, an edifice built without
law collapses, just as a skyscraper built without a foundation will
ultimately crumble.
Pakistan is in turmoil and with it the stability
in the region is threatened.
Issues of poverty, gender equality and minority
rights are calling for attention, as are the issues of unemployment
and inflation.
As the military junta rules, religious
fundamentalists take up more political space at the cost of political
forces. Pakistan could be threatened with an Islamic revolution. But
this revolution would be nuclear armed. The "Talibanization"
of Pakistan can literally threaten world peace.
Ladies and gentlemen, the story of Pakistan did
not have to turn out this way, and I am convinced that ultimately
things will be very different.
The democratic government I led did its best to
create a new, modern Pakistan. With the mandate and support of the
people we marketed the country as a crossroads to the Gulf, Central
and South Asia.
We advanced our country as a model of Islamic
moderation.
We committed ourselves to education, with
special programs targeted to female illiteracy.
We committed ourselves to immunization and
children's health. We committed ourselves to family planning and
population control.
We transformed the country into a center for
financial and commercial investment, creating jobs and wealth. We
created the physical infrastructure, the roads, the electricity, and
the power plants, to sustain a modern, developed economy.
After my overthrow and charges of corruption,
the international community stepped back and foreign investment in
Pakistan dried up. . Businessmen clearly prefer stable economies and
stable markets, in countries governed by the rule of law, where
contracts are honored and commitments fulfilled.
The absence of law also intimidated domestic
investment as well. Martial law and economic development are mutually
exclusive, they cannot exist together.
The dignity of our financial system is
correlated with the destruction of legitimate political institutions,
proving once again, just like the international divestiture movement
against South Africa under apartheid, democracy and economic
development must proceed simultaneously.
It is such times that test the mettle of real
leadership. Ironically, but repeatedly, history tells us that the best
of leadership is constructed in the worst of times.
I welcome the Commonwealth's and the
international support for democracy in Pakistan.
Under that pressure, the Generals recently
permitted local elections. My party supporters emerged as the single
largest winners even though they fought without me on the ground and
without the party symbol on the ballot. We proved against all odds
that democracy is irrepressible, that ultimately the people will
prevail.
The question before my nation is how many will
suffer imprisonment, deprivation, discrimination, poverty and even
death before justice and the forces of history restore the democratic
order.
And although I know not the answer to that
question, I know it is my obligation to lead this battle once again,
no matter what the personal price, to restore a democratic Pakistan.
It is not necessarily the life I would have
chosen for myself. But it seems to be the life that chose me. And in
the words of President John Kennedy, "I do not shrink from this
responsibility, I welcome it."
For leadership is born of a passion, and it is a
commitment. A commitment to an idea, to a people, to a land. I travel,
never knowing when I will be able to see my husband. He has been in
prison for the fifth year running, a hostage of my political career.
I travel and miss my children. They are all
under thirteen. It is difficult explaining to little children why
their mother can't be with them, why their father is a political
prisoner.
I am reconciled to the fact that the needs of my
140 million people come first, and will always come first.
For those in the feminist movement who say that
woman can have it all simultaneously, I urge they look at my life.
Women can have it all but Women have to make difficult choices, often
choices that men are not forced to make. And we must live with the
consequences, for better or worse.
It is not always easy. But we do it for all the
woman who came before us who gave us this opportunity. And most of
all, we do it for all woman who will come after us -- the baby girls
yet unborn!
Ladies and gentlemen, to succeed as a political
leader, one must be on call all the time, like an Emergency Room
doctor, but unlike a doctor, without a moment's break. On call for
good news and bad. On call to respond quickly, to think quickly to
move quickly.
I was brought up in a political family. In a
way, I was groomed for politics. Yet, a political role was not one
that I actively sought. It came to me through an accident of fate.
I had just completed my education and returned
to Pakistan in 1977 when the tanks rumbled up the road in Rawalpindi
and troops took over the Prime Minister's House. My younger siblings
had to go back to their studies.
I stayed behind and was pulled into the
political campaign by the arrest of senior party leaders. That put an
end to my career goal to join the Foreign Service in Pakistan and
become High Commissioner to England or Ambassador to the US, the two
countries I had studied in and knew well.
Fate took over my life and my destiny was no
longer in my hands.
Thus, some are born to leadership, whilst others
have leadership thrust upon them. Many women leaders, particularly in
South Asia, have been thrown into political waters. The assassin's
bullet, the sound of boots or tragedy has thrust them into a role they
might otherwise not have chosen. Yet they are more than extensions of
the male members of their families.
Each woman leader has had to win her badge of
courage and recognition.
As a child of my age, in the late sixties, I was
influenced by the social ferment around me. The worldwide students
movement, from Rawalpindi, to France, to Washington, were important
factors in my youth. The fight against apartheid shaped the ferocity
of my commitment to stand up for principle. Kate Millet and the
burgeoning movement for women's race empowered me and emboldened me.
As an Asian at Harvard, I bitterly resented the
war in Vietnam and joined up with American students to protest a war
that they thought was unjust and did not want to fight.
It was also the time of the impeachment against
President Nixon. A time of moral reawakening, as Martin Luther King
spoke passionately about justice and injustice in America and in South
Africa.
These important steps helped shape my outlook on
life, helped me focus on fighting injustice, promoting freedom and
safeguarding the rights of the weak and dispossessed.
But above all, in America during the Vietnam War
I saw the awesome power of the people changing policies, changing
leaders, and changing history.
From Harvard I went to Oxford.
While I was at Oxford, the Conservative party
chose a woman, Margaret Thatcher, as the Leader of Opposition.
At Oxford, I was the first female foreigner to
be elected as President of the Oxford Union. It was there that I
learned to debate, slowly gaining confidence before an audience.
As the Prime Minister of Pakistan I appeared
before an historic Joint Session of the United States Congress in
1989. In that address, the most meaningful line to me was my simple
message to the woman of America, my message to the women of the world.
Three simple, powerful words: YES YOU CAN!
Don't accept the status quo. Don't accept no for
an answer. Don't accept traditional roles and traditional constraints.
And don't think that leadership and being female are contradictory.
My victory was a victory for women everywhere.
It broke the mind cast of the past.
I was the first woman ever elected head of
government in the Muslim world. Now four others, two in Bangladesh,
one in Turkey and in Indonesia, have followed in my path. One more
glass ceiling is shattered. But thousands are left to break.
The day is not far off when women will join even
the Armed Forces of Pakistan, an idea that I discussed with my service
chiefs in my last tenure. They already began the journey of joining
the judiciary in my last term. The appointment of women judges is
something I am very proud of, as well as the creation of a Women's
Development Bank to make small loans to women entrepreneurs.
And as women enter the work force, it becomes
more sensitive too, to the needs of women and the difficulties in
their lives.
Your record on human, political and economic
rights for woman in South Africa should inspire women all around the
world to keep on pressing, keep on fighting, keep on working for the
rights of equality that cannot forever be denied.
I have attempted, throughout my career, to
combine the best of different experiences.
To build for my people a modern world.
By heralding in the information revolution,
introducing fax machines, digital pagers, optic fiber, cellular
telephones, satellite dishes, Internet, the e-mail and even CNN into
Pakistan.
Under my leadership of de-regulation Pakistan
integrated into the global economy becoming one of the ten emerging
capital markets of the world.
The International Labor Organization's data
showed that the largest job generation in Pakistani history took place
in the PPP government.
The World Bank called our energy program a model
to the entire developing world.
The President of the World Health Organization
gave me a gold medal in recognition of our efforts to improve the
health of our children by eliminating polio and reducing infant
mortality.
We increased literacy rates by one third and
secured women's rights by signing the Convention for the Elimination
of Discrimination Against Women in Beijing.
We brought down the population growth rate
whilst we took up the economic growth rate.
It was a remarkable transformation of a society
for our downtrodden and under privliged people.
That is my legacy to the people of Pakistan.
We believed in education, and we believed in
markets.
We believed in opportunity and we believed in
foreign investment.
We believed in giving our people hope in a
better future.
Ladies and gentlemen,
Despite the travails of the last four years, I
am not bitter.
In my father's last letter to me before he was
murdered by one of Pakistan's many military tyrants, he quoted
Tennyson: "Ah, what shall I be at fifty if I find the world so
bitter at 25."
He had then turned fifty and I twenty five.
He asked me never to be bitter. I have honored
my father's dying wish.
I look at South Africa today and tears come to
my eyes. My faith in humanity and my faith in God are strengthened by
the miracle that has happened here. You -- the people of South Africa
- inspire and empower all of the oppressed, all over the world. My
nation and I remain optimistic about the future, knowing in our hearts
that time, justice and the forces of history are on our side.
Thank you ladies and gentlemen.