Avert Clash of Civilizations
through Justice and Human Rights
Desert Forum - Indian Wells - California USA
24 January 2005

Islamabad, 25 January 2006: "My country Pakistan is an example of a Nation
where the forces of tyranny, terrorism, proliferation and a marginal, yet
militant interpretation of Islam mingle to create an extraordinarily dangerous
challenge. The democratisation of Pakistan is important to the war against
terror, to the interpretation of Islam as a message of freedom and enlightenment
as well as to the empowerment of the people of Pakistan".
This was said by the former Prime Minister and Chairperson Pakistan Peoples
Party, Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto while addressing a distinguished gathering at
Desert Forum attended by intellectuals, academics, policy strategists and
opinion makers in Indian Wells California, USA today.
She said that the question before the world is whether the path to catastrophe
and the clash of civilizations is reversible. "The Pakistani military dictator,
General Pervez Musharraf, has made a choice. And his choice is to stand by and
let terrorists operate freely the territory of Pakistan. These terrorists may
actually control territory where Bin Laden has sanctuary. And the West too has
made a choice"
She said that by acquiescing to the Musharaf dictatorship, they have empowered
him to defy the world and cooperate with the forces of terror. As in all
governing, choices have consequences. The choice to sustain dictatorship in
Pakistan has consequences both in the short and long term that threaten the
interests of the West as well as the values of democracy in the East. Much of
our ability to avert the clash of civilizations lies in learning the lessons of
history.
She said that Islam is a religion of moderation, tolerance and equal right for
all. "Central to the issue of religion in modern society is the treatment of
women. In the post September 11th environment, the true nature of Islam has been
so distorted by those who would politicise it, that Islam has become not only
something foreign to the rest of the world but also something feared"
She said "There is no religion on earth that, in its writings, is more
respectful of the role of women in society than Islam. It is this tradition of
Islam that has allowed me to battle for political and human rights, and
strengthens me today.
Our religion is not only committed to tolerance and equality, but it is
committed to the principles of democracy. The Holy Book says that Islamic
society is contingent on "mutual advice through mutual discussions on an equal
footing." In Islam dictatorship is never condoned, nor is cruelty. The Q'oran,
in its very essence, is an anti-terrorism doctrine, she said.
About the nexus between the extremists and the military dictatorship in Pakistan
she said, It is well known that there is sympathy for Bin Laden, the Taliban,
and the insurrectionists in Iraq among Pakistan's military and clerical class.
These were the two entities used to train the Mujahideen against the Soviet
occupation of Afghanistan. They were armed and supported by the United States,
both overtly and covertly. Following the withdrawal of the Soviets, the
Mujahideen went on to become in large part the Taliban and Al Qaeda.
She said that Pakistan's military dictatorship has resulted in the domination of
the country's political, financial and social class by the military. It has led
to the rise in power and importance of fundamentalist religious parties. These
religious parties are public supporters of Bin Laden and Mullah Omar of
Afghanistan. They have filled the vacuum caused by the military regime's
determination to sideline the genuine representatives of the people of Pakistan.
Extremism has replaced moderation in a despotic Pakistan, she said.
Regarding the fast diminishing image of the lone Superpower the United States
she said, "Sadly, the world's only superpower may have missed a precious
opportunity, may have squandered its unipolar moment to truly lead the world
socially, economically, politically and militarily. Those who have cautioned the
developing world to be responsible and restrained in our fiscal and budgetary
priorities have not practiced what they have preached. And mounting Western debt
threatens the stability of the interconnected global economy. A problematic
intervention in Iraq has lead to tens upon tens of thousands Iraqi deaths, more
than 2300 American and British deaths, and an increase in the U.S. national debt
of 300 billion dollars, with no end in sight to the human and financial costs of
this tragic miscalculation".
Regarding her achievement during the two tenures in the government and the fear
of fundamentalists by change in the society she said, "The extremist's greatest
fear, wherever they live, is the spread of information, social equality and
democracy. These three principles choke off the oxygen of terrorism. Information
leads to change. Change is something that many fear and will not tolerate. I am
proud that we methodologically implemented change in Pakistani society. We
heralded the information age by introducing fax machines, digital papers, fiber
optic communications, cellular telephones, satellite dishes, computers,
Internet, e-mail and even bringing CNN to Pakistan".
She said that under her government Pakistan integrated into the global economy
and it became one of the top ten emerging capital markets of the world,
attracting over 20 billion dollars in foreign investments, particularly in power
generation. We eradicated polio in our country. We dramatically reduced infant
mortality. The World Bank held up our economic program as a model to the entire
developing world. Despite institutional and social constraints, when I became
prime Minister of Pakistan I used my office to try to reverse centuries of
discrimination against women. My tenure was a textbook affirmative action
program against gender discrimination. We increased literacy by one-third, even
more dramatically among girls. We built over 30,000 primary and secondary
schools, targeting rural Pakistan. We brought down the population growth rate by
establishing women's health clinics in thousands of communities across our
Nation.
She said that her government outlawed domestic violence and established special
women's police forces to protect and defend the women of Pakistan. "We appointed
women judges to our nation's benches for the first time in our history. We
instituted a new program of hiring women police officers to investigate crimes
of domestic violence against the women of Pakistan. I systematically appointed
women judges to the courts of the land for the first time. I condemned the
so-called honor killings by members of their own families against women. I
encouraged women's and girl's participation in sports, both nationally and
internationally by lifting the ban imposed on their participation. We believed
that the best way to guarantee literate children is to educate literate mothers,
and thus my government targeted adult women for remedial education programs. I
refused attempts by reactionary forces within my country to turn Pakistan into a
theocracy. We have all prayed for a world of reason, of abundant resources, of
equality and above all, of peace".
Regarding terrorists threat and the US policy Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto said, "In
the closing days of the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan, during a State visit
to America, I cautioned that US policy to defeat the Soviets had empowered and
emboldened the most fanatical, extremist elements of the Afghan seven-faction
Mujahideen at the expense of the moderates, creating a "Frankenstein" that could
come back to haunt us in the future. Yet the early decisions by Western nations
with the then-Pakistani regime counterpart to arm, train, supply and legitimise
the most extreme fanatics sowed the seeds for the 21s century terrorism that is
now swirling around us, she said.
She said that just as the Pakistani dictator Zia ul Haq played the West like a
fiddle over Afghanistan, the Pakistani dictator Pervez Musharaf plays America
like a fiddle over the war on terror. The fundamental mistake that lead
ultimately to the creation of Al Qaeda out of the remnants of the Afghan Jihad
and thus contributed to a long-term historical calamity, was that we were not
consistently committed to the values of freedom, democracy, social equality and
self-determination that ultimately undermine and belie the basic tenets of
terrorism.
Regarding the double standards displayed by the West she said, "Unfortunately,
we do not always view the world -- its peoples, its cultures and its religions
-- with a single moral standard. The West chooses to apply human rights
standards when politically expedient, not as a central and universal principle
of policy, she said.
She said that only electoral process can not guarantee human liberation and
prosperity. She said that liberty and freedom depend on social and economic
justice, and above all on the universal, non-selective application of human
rights to all citizens of the world. She said that democracy is not just about
elections. It is equally about governing.
"Justice is economic independence. Justice is social
equality. Nations make choices. And choices lead to consequences -- political
consequences, economic consequences, social consequences. And these consequences
are intertwined. They are difficult to separate. The child who is starving has
no human rights. The girl who is illiterate has no
future. The woman who cannot plan her life, plan her family, plan a career, is
fundamentally not free -- irrespective of constitutions and elections. Economic
development and political development are surely linked, but both are predicated
on guaranteed human rights. And the cause of human rights must begin within us,
within our individual communities and within our own nations".