A political party is best judged for its performance
over time by two fundamentals. One is the voters it pulls, and the
second is the policy programme it stands for. On both counts the
Pakistan Peoples Party emerges as the only mainstream party in Pakistan
that has not just addressed these fundamentals succesfully over fourty
years since it was founded, but has also steered a course for
progressive politics through global shifts and national crises.
The PPP is not just a political party. It has long
stood for an idea that embraces the most heroic of human impulses: that
shared aspirations, democratic politics and public interest can be
wedded to a national dynamic for change in a fractured backdrop. In a
post-colonial milieu, the only political party that challenged an
oppressive status quo has been the PPP, and for this reason alone it has
drawn to it the hopes and dreams of over two generations of Pakistanis
seeking better lives. Its greatest success has been in responding to
economic and social imperatives over four decades without losing its
signature brand of progressive solutions. Its greatest challenge has
been to survive the corrosive de-politicisation of Pakistani society
over years of illegitimate military rule.
Pakistan
has always been a poor-based social pyramid. The PPP has always sought
to flatten that social pyramid. Social and economic justice have been at
the heart of the party's policy engines, right from the socialist
60s,through the market-driven 90s, and now the global capital
millennium. As its core values, the party has retained a decisive mix of
security for the vulnerable, the women, the minorities, the peasants and
labour. If labour coalitions and peasant hunger drove the industrial
relations and agricultural credit and resource policies of the
first-generation PPP, the creation of a strong middle class and market
deregulations drove the second generation governments which lay the
groundwork for social nets and strong public sector services for a
population still much in need of state interventions.
Shaheed
Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto became known as the father of modern Pakistan,
because he brought public issues out of the feudal-bussiness combine
that dominated political culture in Pakistan. His introduction of issues
that addressed mass-interests, fixed minimum wages and lowered land
ceilings was what defined the iconic programme of the PPP. His name
holds cult status in many parts of Pakistan today because he drew an
entire political class , from the darkness of the urban ghetto and the
dirt-poor village, into the sunshine of public life. The 1971 government
of SZAB is still remembered as a powerhouse of pro-active public action,
crippled by the truncation of Pakistan, but empowered by the will of a
sovereign people. Unlike later PPP governments, which had to face the
military-bureacracy combine's subversions right from the beginning of
each term, the first Bhutto cabinet only fell afoul of massive
right-wing envy towards the end of its term. Before the judicial murder
of Bhutto Shaheed took place, he had put in place strong policy measures
for the mass of the poor he routinely addressed. Within seven weeks of
coming into office, the PPP announced, in February 1972, a new deal for
workers which provided dignity and a fair return to labour. This was the
first government that ensured security of employment by making arbitrary
dismissal challengeable in Labour Courts. By law, workers were made
stakeholders in business by giving them a profit share. This alone
resulted in the distribution of Rs. 50 million to 200,000 workers in
1974 alone. It was the PPP government, that for the first time,
established an Old Age Benefit Scheme as well as Group Insurance Schemes
for all permanent workers while a minimum bonus was made mandatory. In
1988, Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto's government also blazed a trail in
protecting labour. Post-retirement pension was made an entitlement for
all citizens and housing colonies were established in every city. The
thorny issue of child labour as well as bonded labour was
institutionally addressed, and placed in the context of a human rights
response. Hundreds of state prosecutions took place over child labour
cases, and impunity became a problem for bonded labour.
But urban poor constituencies were not the only
stakeholders empowered by the PPP. Peasants were empowered by three PPP
governments through land allotments, easy credit, access to tractors,
seeds and other inputs. If the first PPP government went for aggressive
public interventions in a labour and peasant framework, the second and
third PPP governments responded to a changing global environment by
securing pro-poor interests in a more deregulated context. Better
governance, higher development indices and a high definition of human
rights values percolated down to the grassroots. In this context,
particularly following the trauma of the Zia years, women, minorities
and the media always got the attention of PPP government, from the
rights written in for them in the 1973 Constitution to the institutional
entitlements ushered in by Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto's two governments.
Despite the limited time the last two PPP governments
had, their role in pursuing a pro-women agenda is acknowledged even
today by independent organisations that work with public sector bodies
on gender mainstreaming projects . It was Ms Bhutto's government that
set up a Human Rights Ministry to watch and investigate human rights
abuses, particularly those against women. In February 1996, in a move
acknowledged by all women's activists in the country, and against a
cacophony of strong right-wing pressures, Pakistan ratified the United
Nations' Convention for the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination
Against Women (CEDAW). This was a major achievement of the People's
Party Government on international covenants related to the rights of
women, and to this day is used as a critical benchmark by rights
activists when measuring government performance in this area.
Much is
made today, as it should be, of the need for crisis centres for women in
Pakistan. The first such centres were established by the PPP government
under Ms Bhutto. Legal aid centres and burn units in hospitals were
instituted in response to domestic violence complaints, for the first
time in Pakistan, and as the government was dismissed, a Domestic
Violence Bill was caught in the cracks of political changes. On the
development side, the largest credit programme was established for easy
credit for women, a full-fledged Women's Bank set up and the first
vocational training programme for women got going. Targetting public
health as a poor woman's burden, the PPP government set up the largest
public sector program of Lady Health Workers, which established a vast
network of 133,000 health practitioners to service rural and urban
households in Pakistan, exclusively to cater to women's health needs as
well as to address reproductive health issues. These women health
workers today constitute all that is left of Pakistan's public health
sector backbone, and is touted by all governments as Pakistan's
showpiece health programme. This is by no means all. After the
institution of a job quota for women in public service, which was
quietly reversed by the Musharraf regime, women judges were appointed
all over the High courts and District courts, and a network of Women's
Police Stations set up.
It was the PPP which once again, begun the process of
dismantling the Hudood Ordinances bit by bit both by executive order and
acts of parliament in 1996, when whipping was abolished as a punishment,
and all women booked under the Hudood were released as well as
rehabilitated. Bhutto's government instituted the new National
Commission on the Status of Women under Nasir Aslam Zahid, which paved
the way for the repeal debate on the Hudood Ordinances.
Even in the post-Zia days, the PPP was in the
frontlines of the struggle to reverse the draconian laws introduced by
Zia, its membership on the streets swelling the ranks of the new women's
groups that had come up in resistance to the reactionary politics of the
General. In 2002, it was the PPP again, with the specific backing of Ms
Bhutto, which introduced the first legislation to completely repeal the
odious Hudood Ordinances. In fact, it was the PPP's constant pressure
through private member's bills that led the Musharraf regime to finally
respond with a Women's Bill, which again was steered and amended in
committee by the PPP. As most will recall, the party made history by
voting on issue with the government, when all others voted against,
while the treasury benches had 44 votes absent.
As a vehicle for political participation too, the PPP
has always been the only home for progressive politics on a consistent
grounding. This is the ultimate litmus test of a party's appeal for its
loyal vote bank, and that is one of the reasons why the PPP has
withstood massive exogenous pressures to hold on to its famous federal
constitutuency. This is also why the establishment of non-democratic
players has always been afraid of the PPP, and Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto
as it popular leader. This is still the only party that can mobilise a
loyal cadre on a point of principle, for years at a stretch, without
flinching, without denting its appeal. The PPP's ability to stand up to
any amount of pressure is rooted in its legitimacy in the eyes of its
voters. They know that " Benazir Aye Gee Rozgar Layee Gee" is a demand
in addition to their growing thirst for what the PPP first delivered in
recognising the basic dignity to its voters and promising them " Roti,
Kapra aur Makan" as an inalienable right.
Today, as Pakistan stands at another crossroads in
its trauma-filled history, it is only Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto's vision
that can lead the country out of the flames of extremism and
dictatorship that threaten to engulf it. Once again, the difficult task
of identifying the enemies of the state and the people falls squarely on
the shoulders of the PPP. It has always understood the dynamics of
resisting non-democratic rule. It has also never used religion as a
vehicle to propagate violence, politics or subvert the rule of law. It
makes no apologies for militants and sees the threat to Pakistan as its
own challenge, not anyone else's war. Mohtarma Bhutto's vision to send
all children to schools, to give all women choices and security, to give
all young people an opportunity, to give minorities protection, to give
media the right to free speech, to give business a stable climate, to
give every Pakistani access to clean water, to a doctor, to mobility, to
make government responsive, to give citizens the right to freedom and
liberty is not just a dream. It is a consistent vision powered by the
largest democratic party in the country. This is the party that seeks to
provide social justice in a pluralistic framework, where all provinces
have access to their own resources and empower their own people. And
this is the only party that can save Pakistan today.
Sherry Rehman is the former
Editor of the newsmagazine, Herald and Central Information Secretary of
the Pakistan Peoples